Update on Charvin Water-soluble Pastels

This past summer I reviewed these pastels and compared them to other pastels I own. You can find this review here:  Charvin Review

 I used these exclusively for underpaintings during the 30 paintings in 30 days challenge in September.

Charvin watersoluable pastel ncwren
I found that they worked better with more water than I had been using Before they would clump up and not move around or melt. They are working great as an underpainting. I have still yet to try them as a stand alone pastel.
charvin watercoluable pastels underpainting ncwren
This painting is available for purchase.